Potential pitfalls under the work for hire doctrine. Thus, even if the programs had not been a work made for hire, ownership nonetheless would have vested in mediachase. Work made for hire doctrine does not generally apply to computer. Mar 01, 2016 can software be created as a work for hire. Many contracts still use work made for hire language left over from that time. Moreover, given the nature of computer programming today, a program is no.
Work made for hire doctrine does not generally apply to. The work for hire doctrine becomes more complicated when the author of the work is not an employee but an independent contractor. Copyright, independent contractors, and the workforhire. It is very important that employers clear up issues at the outsetbefore the work is performed. It then analyzes the case law interpreting the work made for hire provisions of. Misconceptions about work made for hire article by.
That can change, however, if that original piece of work was created by someone who is working for another individual or a business. Importantly, even if your employer does not acquire ownership of the patent under one of these two methodsthe preinvention assignment or the workforhire doctrinethe employer may still acquire a limited right to use your patent called a shop right without paying you. For example, a small business that hires a web page design firm to create a company site must make certain that the contract stipulates that the design is a work made for hire. Software development agreements ensure i the orderly transfer of in the software from the developer to the company i. Therefore even if the work a commissioning party wishes to claim ownership interest in falls. Normally, the creator of a software code, a video, or some other original work automatically holds its. China patents, copyrights, and works made for hire china. A work made fore hire can occur in two separate ways.
The significance of this doctrine is that, as the owner of the work, an employer will own all exclusive rights to the work and may freely commercialize the property to its fullest. The ownership of software copyright in offshore outsourcing. In the united states, s exist from the moment that original works of authorship such as poetry, software code, and musical works are fixed in any tangible medium of expression such as paper and ink or flash memory cards. This is a significant finding because it is far from clear that software falls under the work for hire doctrine at all. And, yet, there are many examples of companies hiring an independent software developer to develop code under a work for hire agreement, and it is later determined that the written agreement did not adequately assign rights to the specially made software to the company. The first method is by an employee with in the scope of employment. It then analyzes the case law interpreting the work. It is not, however, one of the enumerated categories of works that qualifies as a work for hire in the statute. Software modules developed as part of a larger it project can be contributions to a collective work and thus works made for hire. However, keep in mind that the workforhire doctrine only applies to s. In the event it should be established that such work does not. Potential pitfalls under the work for hire doctrine cuddy. Nonprofits and the work made for hire doctrine charity.
Work for hire law and legal definition uslegal, inc. In response to these concerns, the courts developed the work for hire doctrine. In contrast, the for a work for hire is owned by the company that hires the person to create the work or pays for the development of the work. At these times, the software industry was booming, use of independent contractors to develop software was pervasive, and infringement litigation with regards to software technologies was common. The answer lies in an analysis of the workmadeforhire doctrine in law. Work made for hire doctrine does not generally apply to computer software by james g. However, when commissioning works from independent contractors, additional steps need to be taken to ensure the employer obtains full rights to the work. Works prepared by an employee within the scope of employment. From the moment it is set in a print or electronic manuscript, a sound recording, a computer software program, or other such concrete medium, the. Conceptually, the basis of the work made for hire often shortened to work for hire doctrine is clear. The ninth circuit held that the work made for hire doctrine would apply if usap could show 1 thomason was an employee of partsbinusap. It then analyzes the case law interpreting the work made for hire provisions of the 1976 act and considers the likely results of dis.
Part of thehistory commons, and thelaw commons this article is brought to you for free and open access by yale law school legal scholarship repository. The work made for hire doctrine generally defines the relationship between a software developer and his or her client. The distinction between an employee and an independent contractor is governed by the rules of agency law and is frequently a factspecific issue. Instead, the employer is solely entitled to exploit the work and profit from it. The work made for hire doctrine started in the courts and. Works made for hire in the united states the workmadeforhire doctrine governs authorship of able works by employees and independent contractors. This is a significant finding because it is far from clear that software falls under the workforhire doctrine at all. Startup and technologyemployees and the use of contracts in a hiring relationship john m.
There are a couple of distinct ways that a work will be classified as made for hire. Under the laws of the united states and certain other jurisdictions, if a work is made for hire, you, the employernot the employeeis considered the legal author. Before the work begins, all parties must agree to sign a document that states the work will be considered a work made for hire. This is why many independent contractor agreements contain a work made for hire clause. As a general rule, the creator of an original work e. It is surprising how many software development contracts with independent contractors rely on a designation of deliverables as works for hire to give the customer ownership of s in the deliverables. The work for hire doctrine applies when employees create works within the scope of their employment or a situation where a certain type of work is specially ordered or commissioned by which an express agreement is to be considered a work for hire freiburn, 2004.
Computer software as a work made for hire henry park law. The work made for hire sometimes abbreviated to work for hire or wfh doctrine is an exception to the general rule that the person who actually creates a work is the legallyrecognized author of that work. In fact, the work for hire doctrine rarely if ever applies to the types of deliverables prepared under these types of contracts. The work made for hire status of a work will effect the length of protection and termination rights as discussed below. Note that even should a commissioned work fall within one of the categories, the statute raises a further barrier to the application of the work for hire doctrine. When a work is deemed one made for hire, authorship is attributed not to the original creator of the work, but to the employer of the author or the commissioner of the work.
Rather, the employer or party who commissioned the work obtains these rights. It is an exception to the general rule that the person who actually creates a work is the legally recognized author of that work. In addition, under the employment agreement the plaintiff was obligated to assign ownership. Likewise, and even more interesting, is that the actual definition for work for hire was modified by congress in 1999 and in 2000. The 1976 act provides that an employer is the author of a work made for hire, but it also describes a work made for hire as a work prepared by an employee within the scope of his or her employment.
Workforhire arrangements affect small businesses in a variety of ways. Any work performed by the executive under this agreement should be considered a work made for hire as the phrase is defined by the u. Under the current statute, there are only two ways that the work made for hire doctrine can apply to graphic artists. The employer can be a firm, an organization, or an individual.
Mar 24, 2014 a work made for hire is 1 a work prepared by an employee within the scope of his or her employment. A work created by an independent contractor can be a work made for hire only if it falls within one of the listed categories and there is a written agreement between parties specifying that the work is a work made for hire. This is true in the united states and in china and in most every other country in the world. Jun 01, 2008 it is surprising how many software development contracts with independent contractors rely on a designation of deliverables as works for hire to give the customer ownership of s in the deliverables. Oct 20, 2015 the workmadeforhire doctrine generally defines the relationship between a software developer and his or her client. The work for hire doctrine as it applies to software programs is still very much unsettled law, and works created by independent contractors will arguably become works made for hire only under very specific, defined circumstances and with a lot of help from your agreements with your independent contractors. The distinction between an employee and an independent contractor is governed by the rules of agency law. Copyright, computer software, and work made for hire. A work made for hire is 1 a work prepared by an employee within the scope of his or her employment.
A software program created by a staff programmer within the scope of his or her duties at a software firm. First, if you are a regular employee, your employer will. This article describes the realities of software development and the history of the work made for hire doctrine. The law maintains that when the program is created by a person employed by another party, the program is considered work made for hire, and the party for whom the work was prepared is the author and has the. Works made for hire in the united states the work made for hire doctrine governs authorship of able works by employees and independent contractors. By comparison of the corresponding regulations on ownership of software.
The work made for hire doctrine maintains that an employer will own all exclusive rights to the work made by employees. The work for hire doctrine is one of the most confusing subjects facing many employers. Common misconception of ownership under the work for hire. The concept of work made for hire can be complicated. Apr 28, 2016 the work comes within one of the nine categories of works listed in part 2 of the definition, and. First, if you are a regular employee, your employer will own any work you do within the scope of your employment automatically as work made for hire. This is true even if the developers strategize, plan, develop, and test the new software. Ownership issues underlying the work made for hire doctrine. The workmadeforhire doctrine generally defines the relationship between a software developer and his or her client.
The main exception to the general rule is for works for hire, which are works commissioned and paid for by a third party. The work must fall within at least one of the nine categories of. And, yet, there are many examples of companies hiring an independent software developer to develop code under a work for hire agreement, and it is later determined that the written agreement did not adequately assign rights to. The best approach is to include an appropriate intellectual property assignment in the contract, assigning the deliverables from the independent contractor to the hiring company. In the event it should be established that such work does not qualify as a work made for hire. In the realm of law, works for hire is a term that refers to the general situation in which a creator of a work, who would otherwise retain rights in the work, gives up rights in the work. For example, it is a common misconception that software qualifies as a work for hire. That can change, however, if that original piece of work was created by someone. A segment of software code is a work made for hire if it is either.
Thus, the plaintiffs employment status provided an independent basis for invoking the work for hire doctrine. The work made for hire doctrine is a major exception to the fundamental principle that ownership vests in the person who created the work. Theres a bit of mystery surrounding the work made for hire doctrine, especially when it comes to independent contractors that develop software. Only certain kinds of work actually qualify as a work for hire under the statute. The creator holds no rights to a work for hire under the law.
A segment of software code is a workmadeforhire if it is either. The bounds of the work for hire doctrine donahue fitzgerald llp. These employeecreated works are known as works made for hire. Copyrights and the work for hire doctrine the ip law blog. The work for hire doctrine almost never works in software. Under the workmadeforhire doctrine, if a software developer is working as the employee of a company, then the employer is considered the author and owns the. The answer lies in an analysis of the work made for hire doctrine in law. Mar 23, 2005 the work for hire doctrine applies when employees create works within the scope of their employment or a situation where a certain type of work is specially ordered or commissioned by which an express agreement is to be considered a work for hire freiburn, 2004. Jul 18, 2017 conceptually, the basis of the work made for hire often shortened to work for hire doctrine is clear.
1282 861 46 245 1176 665 71 67 147 285 635 948 185 737 781 344 1505 621 1499 1515 785 1147 1628 457 367 698 940 786 1499 1256 653 159 614 1427 1293 577 227 1001